2. Gingerbread Person

As soon as we saw it in the display case, we knew that we had to try this adorable, humanoid cookie. Hand-decorated with snowy white icing, the gingerbread person feels like it was made with love and instantly evoked memories of class holiday parties from elementary school. As we took our first bite (the head, of course), we were pleasantly surprised by the strong, warm notes of cinnamon and ginger this cookie packs. While the gingerbread person is a bit too chewy, the flavor and presentation mostly compensate for that deficit.